As the shopping frenzy unfolds, the hidden world of holiday returns takes center stage, reshaping retail policies and giving rise to the booming industry of “Reverse Logistics.” Today, we’re diving into the nitty-gritty and unveiling the strangest items ever returned. Brace yourselves—it’s not always pretty.
There’s a plot twist in the world of online retail—loose return policies are no longer as forgiving. A whopping 44% of retailers are now charging customers for return shipping, up from 33% in 2021, according to Narvar, a post-purchase logistics company. Even retail giants like American Eagle, J.Crew, Saks Fifth Avenue, H&M, and Zara have joined the fee bandwagon.
Why the change? Processing returns costs companies a staggering $165 million for every $1 billion in merchandise sold, says the National Retail Federation. The pandemic-induced surge in online shopping saw a 14% increase in return rates from 2019 to 2022, adding financial strain on retailers. Amazon, the pioneer of free returns, is now feeling the pinch, paying $84.3 billion to process returns last year—more than double the amount in 2019.
Enter the lesser-known hero in the retail saga—reverse logistics. As retailers tighten their return policies, a thriving industry has emerged, capitalizing on the $300 billion worth of returns Americans make every holiday season. Venture capital firms injected nearly $200 million into reverse logistics startups last year, more than doubling the investment in 2021. Established players like Uber and UPS are also making strategic moves in this space.
Historically, returned items ended up in landfills, but today’s reverse logistics industry focuses on repairing, reselling, and recycling unwanted goods. With a societal shift towards sustainability, this industry allows consumers to feel less guilty about making use of that gift receipt.
Returning a pair of jeans might seem mundane, but it’s a multi-billion dollar activity influenced by the psychological phenomenon known as the Refund Effect. Consumers are more likely to spend refunded money, considering it already spent. Retailers aiming to retain that cash in their ecosystem must act swiftly during the return process, offering store credit or exchanges.
With the explosion of online orders during the pandemic, return rates skyrocketed, prompting companies to reevaluate their once-generous return policies. The days of limitless return windows are quietly closing, signaling a shift in the retail landscape.
Returning a gift can be surprisingly enjoyable, especially when met with lenient return policies. Here are some retailers going the extra mile:
Home Depot: A one-year guarantee on certain plants, allowing returns for store credit.
Ikea: Will buy back your old furniture, providing a voucher in return.
Costco: Almost anything can be returned anytime, with a few exceptions.
Trader Joe’s: Virtually all items can be returned for a full refund, even if half-eaten.
Zappos: A full year return window for unworn shoes in the original packaging.
Athleta: A 60-day tryout for workout clothes, a true no-sweat return policy.
As you navigate the Black Friday and Cyber Monday sales, remember to check the return policies. A bad return experience could jeopardize a significant chunk of online sales this season. Happy shopping!
Yours truly,
The Instant Refund Expert™Follow me on X and IG @refundsblog
The Refunds Blog 